Skip to main content

One Clock Is Not Enough

The degeneracy

A single clock measures a single number: the potential at its own location, \(\Phi = -M/r\). Every combination of mass and distance with the same ratio produces exactly the same reading. A small mass nearby is indistinguishable from a heavy mass far away — the clock simply cannot tell you which world it lives in.

Code
import numpy as np
from clocks import ClockArray, MassConfig, clock_rates

clock = ClockArray(positions=np.array([[0.0]]))
near_light = MassConfig(positions=np.array([[2.0]]), masses=np.array([0.04]))
far_heavy = MassConfig(positions=np.array([[4.0]]), masses=np.array([0.08]))
print(f"near light mass: rate = {clock_rates(near_light, clock)[0]:.6f}")
print(f"far heavy mass:  rate = {clock_rates(far_heavy, clock)[0]:.6f}")
near light mass: rate = 0.979796
far heavy mass:  rate = 0.979796

Two visibly different universes, one identical clock reading. This is the same mass–distance degeneracy that haunted the 19th-century hunt for Neptune: a perturbation in Uranus’s orbit could be explained by a lighter planet nearby or a heavier one farther out, and only more geometry — more independent measurements — could split the difference.

Breaking it with geometry

Each additional clock at a different position samples the potential somewhere else. One clock pins down \(M/r\); several clocks pin down how the field falls off, and the falloff is what separates distance from mass. Triangulation, by time dilation. This time the clocks also sit at a perpendicular offset (track_offset=2.0) from the line the mass lives on, which keeps every clock far enough from both candidate masses for the weak-field model to apply. Later pages keep an offset of this kind.

Code
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
from clocks.viz import THEMES, show, style

positions = np.array([[-6.0], [-3.0], [0.0], [3.0], [6.0]])
array5 = ClockArray(positions=positions, track_offset=2.0)
series = [
    ("near light mass (x=2, M=0.04)", "o", clock_rates(near_light, array5)),
    ("far heavy mass (x=4, M=0.08)", "s", clock_rates(far_heavy, array5)),
]

for theme in THEMES:
    with style(theme) as colors:
        fig, ax = plt.subplots()
        for (label, marker, rates), color in zip(
            series, (colors.belief, colors.belief_alt)
        ):
            ax.plot(
                positions[:, 0], rates, marker=marker,
                label=label, color=color,
            )
        ax.set_xlabel("clock position")
        ax.set_ylabel("tick rate")
        ax.legend()
        show(fig)

Across a 5-clock array the two configurations are no longer twins. The heavy mass’s dip is deeper and extends farther to the right, so the five readings differ.

Across a 5-clock array the two configurations are no longer twins. The heavy mass’s dip is deeper and extends farther to the right, so the five readings differ.

With the clocks lifted off the track, even the \(x = 0\) reading is no longer shared — and the clocks at \(x = 3\) and \(x = 6\), on the side where the masses sit, disagree about five times more strongly. The disagreement carries the information.

NoteThe noise floor

With observation noise \(\sigma\), rate differences smaller than \(\sigma\) are hard to see in a single reading. That is why every demo on this site feeds the filter many noisy observations rather than one perfect one: each new reading shrinks the set of worlds consistent with the data. How to do that shrinking honestly is the subject of the next page.